Payroll is both simultaneously critical to business success and extremely challenging to execute well. In fact, nearly all organizations either outsource or use some kind of payroll technology service to manage the function, according to advisory firm Deloitte.
That might be because the payroll function tends to be rife with error otherwise. Payroll teams are spending a lot of time correcting errors and answering questions for employees from employees constantly. It's a huge time investment.
One of the most common areas of confusion and error: understanding and managing the differences between gross pay vs. net pay. While these concepts might seem initially straightforward, they can cause big problems in payroll processing if not fully understood and differentiated accurately.
To start, gross pay refers to the total amount of money an employee earns before any deductions. It includes all forms of compensation, such as base salary, overtime pay, bonuses, and any other additional earnings. For salaried employees, this is usually the annual salary divided by the number of pay periods. For hourly workers, it is the number of hours worked multiplied by the hourly rate.
The formula to determine gross pay for salaried employees is Annual Salary / Number of Pay Periods = Gross Pay Per Period. So, for example, if an employee has an annual salary of $52,000 and is paid bi-weekly (26 pay periods), their gross pay per period would be $52,000 / 26 = $2,000.00.
For hourly employees, the formula is Hours Worked × Hourly Rate = Gross Pay. In this case, if an employee works 40 hours a week at $25 per hour, their weekly gross pay would be 40 × $25 = $1,000.
Gross pay can also include overtime, commissions, bonuses, and other additional forms of compensation.
Net pay is the amount of money an employee takes home after all deductions have been applied to their gross pay. These deductions can include taxes, health insurance premiums, retirement contributions, and other mandatory or voluntary deductions. The formula to calculate net pay is Gross Pay - Deductions = Net Pay.
In other words, to calculate net pay, add up all the appropriate taxes, deductions, and contributions and subtract the sum from the gross pay. In the sample pay stub, for instance, we subtract $353.21 in taxes and $140 in pre-tax deductions (this employee has no health insurance) from their $2000 gross pay. The net pay is thus $1,506.79.
Understanding the deductions that affect net pay is crucial for employees to know how much they will receive after each pay period. Perhaps the most important element of an employee’s pay deducted from their gross pay will be taxable wages, or the portion of an employee's gross pay that is subject to taxation.
This typically includes wages, salaries, bonuses, and other forms of compensation, but there may be some exclusions. For example, contributions to a traditional 401(k) plan are not typically subject to federal income tax withholding, but they are still subject to FICA taxes. Knowing what taxable wages are is crucial for employers to ensure accurate tax withholding and for employees to understand how deductions affect their net income.
Altogether, common examples of deductions include:
Federal and State Taxes: These are mandatory and vary based on factors like income, filing status, and number of dependents.
Social Security and Medicare (FICA Taxes): These mandatory contributions help fund social programs. Social Security is generally 6.2% of gross pay, and Medicare is 1.45%.
Health Insurance Premiums: Employees may opt to have premiums deducted from their paycheck to cover medical, dental, and vision insurance.
Retirement Contributions: Employees may contribute to retirement plans like 401(k)s or IRAs, often matched by employers up to a certain percentage.
Other Voluntary Deductions: This may include life insurance, union dues, or charitable donations.
The distinction between gross pay vs net pay is important for employers for several reasons:
Cost Forecasting and Budgeting: Gross pay reflects the full compensation cost, including salaries, overtime, and bonuses. This helps employers to budget accurately for overall payroll expenses, which is critical for managing cash flow and aligning financial planning with business goals.
Employee Satisfaction: Clear communication about pay, including how to calculate gross salary accurately and understanding deductions correctly, can help build trust between employers and employees. It avoids confusion or disputes about compensation.
Tax Compliance: Employers must withhold the correct amount of taxes from gross pay. Understanding what are taxable wages and accurately distinguishing gross pay vs. net pay ensures compliance with federal, state, and local tax laws.
Ensure Accuracy: Common errors associated with gross pay vs. net pay include incorrect tax withholding, errors in benefit deductions, inconsistent payroll periods, and incorrect handling of pre-tax and post-tax deductions. These issues can lead to discrepancies in gross and net pay that can have tax implications for both employee and employer and, if handled poorly, result in penalties and create vulnerability to litigation.
It’s essential for employers to regularly review and audit their payroll processing to ensure all deductions are correct and that they are calculating the correct net pay, especially if they are trying to handle it manually and in-house. When reviewing or auditing payroll, make sure to check all of the following:
Check Gross Pay: Verify the total earnings match the expected salary or hours worked.
Review Deductions: Ensure all deductions are accurate. Pay attention to tax amounts and any voluntary deductions (e.g., retirement or health insurance).
Confirm Net Pay: Make sure the final amount matches what is scheduled to be paid.
Understand Taxable Wages: Some deductions can affect taxable wages. For instance, pre-tax contributions to health savings accounts (HSAs) reduce taxable wages, which lowers tax liability.
Ready to elevate your payroll practices? Download our free e-book on the top payroll trends for 2025 and stay ahead of the curve! Get your e-book now!